That was not what I said, because such was not the language of Mr. Forsyth to M. Pageot.  On refusing the copy offered to him by that charge d’affaires Mr. Forsyth gave as the only reason that it was a document of which he could make no use, and that was the phrase repeated by me.

Mr. Forsyth made no objection to the form which I had adopted to communicate to the Federal Government the views of the King’s Government; in fact, not only is there nothing unusual in that form, not only is it employed in the intercourse between one government and another whenever there is a desire to avoid the irritation which might involuntarily arise from an exchange of contradictory notes in a direct controversy, but reflection on the circumstances and the respective positions of the two countries will clearly show that it was chosen precisely in a spirit of conciliation and regard for the Federal Government.

Finally, sir, after having said, “If the Government of the United States does not give this assurance we shall be obliged to think that this misunderstanding is not the result of an error,” I did not add, “and the business will stop there.”  This last error is, however, of so little importance that I hesitated to notice it.  Receive, sir, the assurances of my high consideration.

V. BROGLIE.

No. 5.

Mr. Barton to the Duke de Broglie.

F.

LEGATION OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,

Paris, November 6, 1835.

His Excellency the DUKE DE BROGLIE,

Minister of Foreign Affairs, etc.

MONSIEUR LE DUC:  Having been recalled by my Government, I have the honor to request that your excellency will be pleased to cause passports to be prepared to enable me to proceed to Havre, thence to embark for the United States, and for my protection during the time I may find it necessary to remain in Paris.  I am instructed to give as a reason for my departure the nonexecution on the part of His Majesty’s Government of the convention of July 4, 1831.

I avail myself of this opportunity, Monsieur le Duc, to renew the assurances of very high consideration with which I have the honor to be, your excellency’s most obedient, humble servant,

THOS.  P. BARTON.

No. 6.

The Duke de Broglie to Mr. Barton.

[Translation.]

PARIS, November 8, 1835.

Mr. BARTON,

Charge d’Affaires of the United States of America.

SIR:  Having taken His Majesty’s orders with regard to your communication of the 6th instant, I have the honor to send you herewith the passports which you requested of me.  As to the reasons which you have been charged to advance in explanation of your departure, I have nothing to say (Je n’ai point a m’y arreter).  The Government of the United States, sir, knows that upon itself depends henceforward the execution of the treaty of July 4, 1831.