of the whites the South must rely for its republican
permanence, as on their arms it must rely for its
force; and here again, the words of Sismondi, written
of falling Rome, seem already applicable to the South:
—“Thus all that class of free cultivators,
who more than any other class feel the love of country,
who could defend the soil, and who ought to furnish
the best soldiers, disappeared almost entirely.
The number of small farmers diminished to such a degree,
that a rich man, a man of noble family, had often
to travel more than ten leagues before falling in
with an equal or a neighbor.” The destruction
of the republican form of government is, then, almost
the necessary catastrophe; but what will follow that
catastrophe it is not so easy to foretell. The
Republic, thus undermined, will fall; but what shall
supply its place? The tendency of decaying republics
is to anarchy; and men take refuge from the terrors
of anarchy in despotism. The South least of all
can indulge in anarchy, as it would at once tend to
servile insurrection. They cannot long be torn
by civil war, for the same reason. The ever-present,
all-pervading fear of the African must force them into
some government, and the stronger the better.
The social divisions of the South, into the rich and
educated whites, the poor and ignorant whites, and
the servile class, would seem naturally to point to
an aristocratic or constitutional-monarchical form
of government. But, in their transition state,
difficulties are to be met in all directions; and the
well-ordered social distinctions of a constitutional
monarchy seem hardly consistent with the time-honored
licentious independence and rude equality of Southern
society. The reign of King Cotton, however, conducted
under the present policy, must inevitably tend to increase
and aggravate all the present social tendencies of
the Southern system,— all the anti-republican
affinities already strongly developed. It makes
deeper the chasm dividing the rich and the poor; it
increases vastly the ranks of the uneducated; and,
finally, while most unnaturally forcing the increase
of the already threatening African infusion, it also
tends to make the servile condition more unendurable,
and its burdens heavier.
The modern Southern politician is the least far-seeing
of all our short-sighted classes of American statesmen.
In the existence of a nation, a generation should
be considered but as a year in the life of man, and
a century but as a generation of citizens. Soon
or late, in the lives of this generation or of their
descendants, in the Union or out of the Union, the
servile members of this Confederacy must, under the
results of the prolonged dynasty of Cotton, make their
election either to purchase their security, like Cuba,
by dependence on the strong arm of external force,
or they must meet national exigencies, pass through
revolutions, and destroy and reconstruct governments,
making every movement on the surface of a seething,