But there must be a thorough comprehension in the mind of the Secretary of State of two things—­first of all, of the Indian point of view; and, secondly, the point of view as it appears to those who are the masters of me and of you.  Do not forget that adjustment has to be made.  It would be impertinent of me to pay compliments to the Civil Service, to whom I propose this toast—­“The Health of the Indian Civil Service.”  You might think for a moment, that it was an amateur proposing prosperity and success to experts.  I have had in my days a good deal to do with experts of one kind and another, and I assure you that I do not think an expert is at all the worse when he gets a candid-minded and reasonably well trained amateur.

Now, this year is a memorable anniversary.  It is fifty years within a month or two, since the Crown took over the Government of India from the old East India Company.  Whether that was a good move or a bad move, it would not become me to discuss.  The move was made. (A voice, “It was a good move.”) My veteran friend says that it was a good move.  I hope so.  But at the end of fifty years we are at rather a critical moment.  I read in The Times the other day that the present Viceroy and Secretary of State had to deal with conditions such as the British in India never before were called upon to face. (A voice, “That is so.”) Now, many of you sitting around me at this table are far better able to test the weight of that statement, than I can pretend to be.  Is it true that at the end of fifty years since the transfer to the Crown, we have to deal with conditions such as the British in India never before were called upon to face? ("Yes.”) I cannot undertake to measure that; but what is clear is that decidedly heavy clouds have suddenly risen in our horizon, and are darkly sailing over our Indian skies.  That cannot be denied.  But, gentlemen, having paid the utmost attention that a man can in office, with access to all the papers, and seeing all the observers he is able to see, I do not feel for a moment that this discovery of a secret society or a secret organisation involves any question of an earthquake.  I prefer to look upon it, to revert to my own figure, as clouds sailing through the sky.  I do not say you will not have to take pretty strong measures of one sort and another.  Yes, but strong measures in the right direction, and with the right qualifications.  I think any man who lays down a firm proposition that all is well, or any man who says that all is ill—­either of those two men is probably wrong.  Now this room is filled, and genially filled, with men who have had enormous experience, vast and wide experience, and, not merely passive experience, but that splendid active experience which is the real training and education of men in responsibility.  This room is full of gentlemen with these qualifications.  And I will venture to say that the theories and explanations that could be heard in the palace of truth from all of you gentlemen