Conscript fathers, none of the transactions at Caudium
were directed by human wisdom. The immortal gods
deprived of understanding both your generals and those
of the enemy. On the one side we acted not with
sufficient caution in the war; on the other, they
threw away a victory, which through our folly they
had obtained, while they hardly confided in the places,
by means of which they had conquered; but were in
haste, on any terms, to take arms out of the hands
of men who were born to arms. Had their reason
been sound, would it have been difficult, during the
time which they spent in sending for old men from
home to give them advice, to send ambassadors to Rome,
and to negotiate a peace and treaty with the senate,
and with the people? It would have been a journey
of only three days to expeditious travellers.
In the interim, matters might have rested under a
truce, that is, until their ambassadors should have
brought from Rome, either certain victory or peace.
That would have been really a compact, on the faith
of sureties, for we should have become sureties by
order of the people. But, neither would ye have
passed such an order, nor should we have pledged our
faith; nor was it right that the affair should have
any other issue, than, that they should be vainly
mocked with a dream, as it were, of greater prosperity
than their minds were capable of comprehending, and
that the same fortune, which had entangled our army,
should extricate it; that an ineffectual victory should
be frustrated by a more ineffectual peace; and that
a convention, on the faith of a surety, should be
introduced, which bound no other person beside the
surety. For what part had ye, conscript fathers;
what part had the people, in this affair? Who
can call upon you? Who can say, that he has been
deceived by you? Can the enemy? Can a citizen?
To the enemy ye engaged nothing. Ye ordered no
citizen to engage on your behalf. Ye are therefore
no way concerned either with us, to whom ye gave no
commission; nor with the Samnites, with whom ye transacted
no business. We are sureties to the Samnites;
debtors, sufficiently wealthy in that which is our
own, in that which we can offer—our bodies
and our minds. On these, let them exercise their
cruelty; against these, let them whet their resentment
and their swords. As to what relates to the tribunes,
consider whether the delivering them up can be effected
at the present time, or if it must be deferred to
another day. Meanwhile let us, Titus Veturius,
and the rest concerned, offer our worthless persons,
as atonements for the breaking our engagements, and,
by our sufferings liberate the Roman armies.”