It consists in treating an absurdity with an air as
if it were none; or as if it had been a pure matter
of course, erroneously mistaken for an absurdity.
Thus the good abbot, whose monastery is blockaded by
the giants (for the virtue and simplicity of his character
must be borne in mind), after observing that the ancient
fathers in the desert had not only locusts to eat,
but manna, which he has no doubt was rained down on
purpose from heaven, laments that the “relishes”
provided for himself and his brethren should have
consisted of “showers of stones.”
The stones, while the abbot is speaking, come thundering
down, and he exclaims, “For God’s sake,
knight, come in, for the manna is falling!” This
is exactly in the style of the Dictionnaire Philosophique.
So when Margutte is asked what he believes in, and
says he believes in “neither black nor blue,”
but in a good capon, “whether roast or boiled,”
the reader is forcibly reminded of Voltaire’s
Traveller, Scarmentado, who, when he is desired
by the Tartars to declare which of their two parties
he is for, the party of the black-mutton or the white-mutton,
answers, that the dish is “equally indifferent
to him, provided it is tender.” Voltaire,
however, does injustice to Pulci, when he pretends
that in matters of belief he is like himself,—a
mere scoffer. The friend of Lucrezia Tornabuoni
has evidently the tenderest veneration for all that
is good and lovely in the Catholic faith; and whatever
liberties he might have allowed himself in professed
extravaganzas, when an age without Church-authority
encouraged them, and a reverend canon could take part
in those (it must be acknowledged) unseemly “high
jinks,” he never, in the Morgante, when
speaking in his own person, and not in that of the
worst characters, intimates disrespect towards any
opinion which he did not hold to be irrelevant to
a right faith. It is observable that his freest
expressions are put in the mouth of the giant Margutte,
the lowest of these characters, who is an invention
of the author’s, and a most extraordinary personage.
He is the first unmitigated blackguard in fiction,
and is the greatest as well as first. Pulci is
conjectured, with great probability, to have designed
him as a caricature of some real person; for Margutte
is a Greek who, in point of morals, has been horribly
brought up, and some of the Greek refugees in Italy
were greatly disliked for the cynicism of their manners
and the grossness of their lives. Margutte is
a glutton, a drunkard, a liar, a thief, and a blasphemer.
He boasts of having every vice, and no virtue except
fidelity; which is meant to reconcile Morgante to his
company; but though the latter endures and even likes
it for his amusement, he gives him to understand that
he looks on his fidelity as only securable by the
bastinado, and makes him the subject of his practical
jokes. The respectable giant Morgante dies of
the bite of a crab, as if to spew on what trivial
chances depends the life of the strongest. Margutte
laughs himself to death at sight of a monkey putting
his boots on and off; as though the good-natured poet
meant at once to express his contempt of a merely
and grossly anti-serious mode of existence, and his
consideration, nevertheless, towards the poor selfish
wretch who had had no better training.