surrendered 2 jugera or 2,000 beyond that amount?  Again, considering the outcry made, it is hard to imagine that only those possessing above 500 jugera were interfered with.  But this perhaps may be accounted for by recollecting that in such matters men fight bravely against what they feel to be the thin end of the wedge, even if they are themselves concerned only sympathetically.  What Gracchus meant to do with the slaves displaced by free labour, or how he meant to decide what was public and what was private land after inextricable confusion between the two in many parts for so many years, we cannot even conjecture.  The statesmanlike comprehensiveness, however, of his main propositions justifies us in believing that he had not overlooked such obvious stumbling-blocks in his way. [Sidenote:  Appian’s criticism of the law.] When Appian says he was eager to accomplish what he thought to be a good thing, we concur in the testimony Appian thus gives to Gracchus having been a good man.  But when he goes on to say he was so eager that he never even thought of the difficulty, we prefer to judge Gracchus by his own acts rather than by Appian’s criticism or the similar criticisms of modern writers. [Sidenote:  Speeches of Gracchus explaining his motives.] The speeches ascribed to him, which are apparently genuine, seem to show that he knew well enough what he was about.  ‘The wild beasts of Italy,’ he said, ’have their dens to retire to, but the brave men who spill their blood in her cause have nothing left but air and light.  Without homes, without settled habitations, they wander from place to place with their wives and children; and their generals do but mock them when at the head of their armies they exhort their men to fight for their sepulchres and the gods of their hearths, for among such numbers perhaps there is not one Roman who has an altar that has belonged to his ancestors or a sepulchre in which their ashes rest.  The private soldiers fight and die to advance the wealth and luxury of the great, and they are called masters of the world without having a sod to call their own.’  Again, he asked, ’Is it not just that what belongs to the people should be shared by the people?  Is a man with no capacity for fighting more useful to his country than a soldier?  Is a citizen inferior to a slave?  Is an alien or one who owns some of his country’s soil the best patriot?  You have won by war most of your possessions, and hope to acquire the rest of the habitable globe.  But now it is but a hazard whether you gain the rest by bravery or whether by your weakness and discords you are robbed of what you have by your foes.  Wherefore, in prospect of such acquisitions, you should if need be spontaneously and of your own free will yield up these lands to those who will rear children for the service of the State.  Do not sacrifice a great thing while striving for a small, especially as you are to receive no contemptible compensation for your expenditure on the land, in free ownership of 500 jugera secure for ever, and in case you have sons, of 250 more for each of them.