3.  Was there a conspiracy to raid the I.W.W. hall on the part of the business interests of Centralia?  Verdict, “Yes.”

There was evidence offered by the defense to show that the business interests held a meeting at the Elk’s Club on October 20, 1919, at which ways and means to deal with the I.W.W. situation were discussed.  F.B.  Hubbard, Chief of Police Hughes and William Scales, commander of the American Legion at Centralia, were present.  Prosecuting Attorney Allen was quoted as having said, “There is no law that would let you run the I.W.W. out of town.”  Chief of Police Hughes said, “You cannot run the I.W.W. out of town; they have violated no law.”  F.G.  Hubbard said, “It’s a damn shame; if I was chief I would have them out of town in 24 hours.”  William Scales, presiding at the meeting, said that although he was not in favor of a raid, there was no American jury that would convict them if they did, or words to that effect.  He then announced that he would appoint a secret committee to deal with the I.W.W. situation.

4.  Was the I.W.W. hall unlawfully raided?  Verdict, “Yes.”  The evidence introduced convinces us that an attack was made before a shot was fired.

5.  Had the defendants a right to defend their hall.  Verdict, “yes.”  On a former occasion the I.W.W. hall was raided, furniture destroyed and stolen, ropes placed around their necks and they were otherwise abused and driven out of town by citizens, armed with pick handles.

6.  Was Warren O. Grimm a party to the conspiracy of raiding the I.W.W. hall?  Verdict, “Yes.”  The evidence introduced convinces us that Warren O. Grimm participated in the raid of the I.W.W. hall.

7.  To our minds the most convincing evidence that Grimm was in front of and raiding the I.W.W. hall with others, is the evidence of State Witness Van Gilder who testified that he stood at the side of Grimm at the intersection of Second street and Tower avenue, when, according to his testimony, Grimm was shot.  This testimony was refuted by five witnesses who testified that they saw Grimm coming wounded from the direction of the I.W.W. hall.  It is not credible that Van Gilder, who was a personal and intimate friend of Grimm, would leave him when he was mortally wounded, to walk half a block alone and unaided.

8.  Did the defendants get a fair and impartial trial?  Verdict, “No.”  The most damaging evidence of a conspiracy by the business men of Centralia, of a raid on the I.W.W. hall, was ruled out by the court and not permitted to go to the jury.  This was one of the principal issues that the defense sought to establish.