ago, the Roman system had only an external coherence
and received only a mechanical extension, while internally
it became even with him utterly withered and dead.
If in the early stages of the autocracy and above
all in Caesar’s own soul(5) the hopeful dream
of a combination of free popular development and absolute
rule was still cherished, the government of the highly-gifted
emperors of the Julian house soon taught men in a terrible
form how far it was possible to hold fire and water
in the same vessel. Caesar’s work was necessary
and salutary, not because it was or could be fraught
with blessing in itself, but because— with
the national organization of antiquity, which was based
on slavery and was utterly a stranger to republican-constitutional
representation, and in presence of the legitimate
urban constitution which in the course of five hundred
years had ripened into oligarchic absolutism—
absolute military monarchy was the copestone logically
necessary and the least of evils. When once
the slave-holding aristocracy in Virginia and the
Carolinas shall have carried matters as far as their
congeners in the Sullan Rome, Caesarism will there
too be legitimized at the bar of the spirit of history;(6)
where it appears under other conditions of development,
it is at once a caricature and a usurpation.
But history will not submit to curtail the true Caesar
of his due honour, because her verdict may in the
presence of bad Caesars lead simplicity astray and
may give to roguery occasion for lying and fraud.
She too is a Bible, and if she cannot any more than
the Bible hinder the fool from misunderstanding and
the devil from quoting her, she too will be able to
bear with, and to requite, them both.
Dictatorship
The position of the new supreme head of the state
appears formally, at least in the first instance,
as a dictatorship. Caesar took it up at first
after his return from Spain in 705, but laid it down
again after a few days, and waged the decisive campaign
of 706 simply as consul—this was the office
his tenure of which was the primary occasion for the
outbreak of the civil war.(7) but in the autumn of
this year after the battle of Pharsalus he reverted
to the dictatorship and had it repeatedly entrusted
to him, at first for an undefined period, but from
the 1st January 709 as an annual office, and then
in January or February 710(8) for the duration of
his life, so that he in the end expressly dropped
the earlier reservation as to his laying down the office
and gave formal expression to its tenure for life
in the new title of -dictator perpetuus-. This
dictatorship, both in its first ephemeral and in its
second enduring tenure, was not that of the old constitution,
but—what was coincident with this merely
in the name—the supreme exceptional office
as arranged by Sulla;(9) an office, the functions
of which were fixed, not by the constitutional ordinances
regarding the supreme single magistracy, but by special