from whence their ideas are taken, as from their original,
are apt to be very confused.
Justice is a
word in every man’s mouth, but most commonly
with a very undetermined, loose signification; which
will always be so, unless a man has in his mind a distinct
comprehension of the component parts that complex idea
consists of and if it be decompounded, must be able
to resolve it still only till he at last comes to
the simple ideas that make it up: and unless this
be done, a man makes an ill use of the word, let it
be justice, for example, or any other. I do not
say, a man needs stand to recollect, and make this
analysis at large, every time the word justice comes
in his way: but this at least is necessary, that
he have so examined the signification of that name,
and settled the idea of all its parts in his mind,
that he can do it when he pleases. If any one
who makes his complex idea of justice to be, such
a treatment of the person or goods of another as is
according to law, hath not a clear and distinct idea
what
law is, which makes a part of his complex
idea of justice, it is plain his idea of justice itself
will be confused and imperfect. This exactness
will, perhaps, be judged very troublesome; and therefore
most men will think they may be excused from settling
the complex ideas of mixed modes so precisely in their
minds. But yet I must say, till this be done,
it must not be wondered, that they have a great deal
of obscurity and confusion in their own minds, and
a great deal of wrangling in their discourse with
others.
10. And distinct and conformable ideas in Words
that stand for Substances.
In the names of substances, for a right use of them,
something more is required than barely determined
ideas. In these the names must also be conformable
to things as they exist; but
of this I shall have occasion to speak more at large
by and by. This exactness is absolutely necessary
in inquiries after philosophical knowledge, and in
controversies about truth. And though it would
be well, too, if it extended itself to common conversation
and the ordinary affairs of life; yet I think that
is scarce to be expected. Vulgar notions suit
vulgar discourses: and both, though confused
enough, yet serve pretty well the market and the wake.
Merchants and lovers, cooks and tailors, have words
wherewithal to dispatch their ordinary affairs:
and so, I think, might philosophers and disputants
too, if they had a mind to understand, and to clearly
understood.
11. Third Remedy: To apply Words to such
ideas as common use has annexed them to.