which would convince them that things are not brought
about just after the same manner that they have decreed
within themselves that they are. Would it not
be an insufferable thing for a learned professor,
and that which his scarlet would blush at, to have
his authority of forty years standing, wrought out
of hard rock, Greek and Latin, with no small expense
of time and candle, and confirmed by general tradition
and a reverend beard, in an instant overturned by
an upstart novelist? Can any one expect that he
should be made to confess, that what he taught his
scholars thirty years ago was all error and mistake;
and that he sold them hard words and ignorance at a
very dear rate. What probabilities, I say, are
sufficient to prevail in such a case? And who
ever, by the most cogent arguments, will be prevailed
with to disrobe himself at once of all his old opinions,
and pretences to knowledge and learning, which with
hard study he hath all this time been labouring for;
and turn himself out stark naked, in quest afresh of
new notions? All the arguments that can be used
will be as little able to prevail, as the wind did
with the traveller to part with his cloak, which he
held only the faster. To this of wrong hypothesis
may be reduced the errors that may be occasioned by
a true hypothesis, or right principles, but not rightly
understood. There is nothing more familiar than
this. The instances of men contending for different
opinions, which they all derive from the infallible
truth of the Scripture, are an undeniable proof of
it. All that call themselves Christians, allow
the text that says,[word in Greek], to carry in it
the obligation to a very weighty duty. But yet
how very erroneous will one of their practices be,
who, understanding nothing but the French, take this
rule with one translation to be, REPENTEZ-VOUS, repent;
or with the other, FATIEZ
penitence, do penance.
12. III. Predominant Passions.
Probabilities which cross men’s appetites and
prevailing passions run the same fate. Let ever
so much probability hang on one side of a covetous
man’s reasoning, and money on the other; it is
easy to foresee which will outweigh. Earthly
minds, like mud walls, resist the strongest batteries:
and though, perhaps, sometimes the force of a clear
argument may make some impression, yet they nevertheless
stand firm, and keep out the enemy, truth, that would
captivate or disturb them. Tell a man passionately
in love, that he is jilted; bring a score of witnesses
of the falsehood of his mistress, it is ten to one
but three kind words of hers shall invalidate all
their testimonies. Quod VOLUMUS, facile
CREDIMUS; what suits our wishes, is forwardly believed,
is, I suppose, what every one hath more than once
experimented: and though men cannot always openly
gainsay or resist the force of manifest probabilities
that make against them, yet yield they not to the
argument. Not but that it is the nature of the
understanding constantly to close with the more probable
side; but yet a man hath a power to suspend and restrain
its inquiries, and not permit a full and satisfactory
examination, as far as the matter in question is capable,
and will bear it to be made. Until that be done,
there will be always these two ways left of evading
the most apparent probabilities: