But it is plain that in our complex ideas of substances
are not contained such ideas, on which all the other
qualities that are to be found in them do depend.
The common idea men have of iron is, a body of a certain
colour, weight, and hardness; and a property that
they look on as belonging to it, is malleableness.
But yet this property has no necessary connexion with
that complex idea, or any part of it: and there
is no more reason to think that malleableness depends
on that colour, weight, and hardness, than that colour
or that weight depends on its malleableness.
And yet, though we know nothing of these real essences,
there is nothing more ordinary than that men should
attribute the sorts of things to such essences.
The particular parcel of matter which makes the ring
I have on my finger is forwardly by most men supposed
to have a real essence, whereby it is gold; and from
whence those qualities flow which I find in it, viz.
its peculiar colour, weight, hardness, fusibility,
fixedness, and change of colour upon a slight touch
of mercury, &c. This essence, from which all these
properties flow, when I inquire into it and search
after it, I plainly perceive I cannot discover:
the furthest I can go is, only to presume that, it
being nothing but body, its real essence or internal
constitution, on which these qualities depend, can
be nothing but the figure, size, and connexion of
its solid parts; of neither of which having any distinct
perception at all can I have any idea of its essence:
which is the cause that it has that particular shining
yellowness; a greater weight than anything I know of
the same bulk; and a fitness to have its colour changed
by the touch of quicksilver. If any one will
say, that the real essence and internal constitution,
on which these properties depend, is not the figure,
size, and arrangement or connexion of its solid parts,
but something else, called its particular form,
I am further from having any idea of its real essence
than I was before. For I have an idea of figure,
size, and situation of solid parts in general, though
I have none of the particular figure, size, or putting
together of parts, whereby the qualities above mentioned
are produced; which qualities I find in that particular
parcel of matter that is on my finger, and not in
another parcel of matter, with which I cut the pen
I write with. But, when I am told that something
besides the figure, size, and posture of the solid
parts of that body in its essence, something called
substantial form, of that I confess I have
no idea at all, but only of the sound form; which
is far enough from an idea of its real essence or
constitution. The like ignorance as I have of
the real essence of this particular substance, I have
also of the real essence of all other natural ones:
of which essences I confess I have no distinct ideas
at all; and, I am apt to suppose, others, when they
examine their own knowledge, will find in themselves,
in this one point, the same sort of ignorance.