of this party against Canterbury, which was in the
hands of a monastic chapter. The Bishop of Winchester,
Henry of Blois, could well remember the struggle between
Church and Crown under a far weaker king twenty six
years before, when the bishops had wisely withdrawn
from a contest where they had “seen swords unsheathed
and knew it was no longer a joking matter, but a struggle
of life and death,” and with the prudence born
of long political experience he was for moderate counsels.
The Bishop of Chichester, Hilary, doubtless remembered
the inconvenient part which Thomas as chancellor had
played in his own trial a few years before, and might
gladly recognize a poetic justice in seeing Thomas’s
old doctrines of the supremacy of the State now applied
to himself. “Every plant,” he once
said with taunting reference to the king’s part
in Thomas’s election, “which my heavenly
Father has not planted shall be rooted up.”
Thomas bitterly added another verse as he heard of
the saying, “This man had among the brethren
the place of Judas the traitor.” There
seems to have been a general impression that the position
of the Primate was extremely critical, and he was
besieged by advisers who urged submission, by messengers
from pope and cardinals, by panic-stricken churchmen.
Beset on all sides the Primate wavered, and at last
promised to swear obedience to the “customs of
the kingdom.” Immediately the king summoned
prelates and barons to witness his submission, and
the famous Council of Clarendon met for this purpose
in 1164.
At Clarendon, however, after three days’ conference,
the archbishop hesitated and hung back, he had grievously
sinned in yielding, and he now refused the promised
oath. The bishops, finding courage in his firmness,
declared themselves ready to follow him in his refusal.
At the news the fury of the king burst forth, and
“he was as a madman in the eyes of those who
stood by.” The court broke into wild disorder,
the servants of the king, “with faces more truculent
than usual,” burst into the assembly of the
prelates, and flinging aside their long cloaks, flourished
their axes aloft, and threatened to strike them into
the heads of the bishops. Two nobles were sent
to warn Thomas that orders for his death were already
given unless he would submit. The weeping bishops
with lamentable voices besought him to save them; knights
of the Hospital and the Temple from the king’s
household knelt before him, sighing and pouring forth
tears. “In fear of death,” says one
chronicler, he yielded. “I am ready,”
he said, “to keep the customs of the kingdom.”
Hardly were the words out of his mouth, when Henry
commanded him to order the bishops to give the same
promise, and again the Primate obeyed. But the
king was still unsatisfied. His temper had risen
in the discussions of the last few months; his determination
was fixed that the matter should be settled once for
all. With the sharp decision of a keen and practical
administrator, he ordered that the “customs of