his pledge, that while he was chancellor he put an
end to the abuse of keeping bishoprics and abbeys
vacant. He had, however, as was said at the time,
“put off the deacon” to put on the chancellor;
and in an ecclesiastical trial which took place soon
after Henry’s crowning, he appears as an energetic
exponent of the king’s legal views. A dispute
had raged for years as to the jurisdiction of the bishops
of Chichester over the abbots of Battle. On Henry’s
accession Bishop Hilary of Chichester vigorously renewed
the struggle, and a great trial was held in May 1157
to decide the matter. Hilary failing after much
discussion to effect a compromise, emphatically and
solemnly declared in words such as Henry was to hear
a few years later from another mouth, that there were
two powers, secular and spiritual, and that the secular
authority could not interfere with the spiritual jurisdiction,
or depose any bishop or ecclesiastic without leave
from Rome. “True enough, he cannot be ‘deposed,’”
cried the young king, “but by a shove like this
he may be clean thrust out!” and he suited the
action to the words. A laugh ran round the assembly
at the king’s jest; but Hilary, taking no notice
of the hint, went on to urge that no layman, not even
the king, could by the law of Rome confer ecclesiastical
dignity or exemptions without the Pope’s leave
and confirmation. “What next!” broke
in Henry angrily, “you think with your practised
cunning to set yourself up against the authority of
my kingly prerogative granted me by God Himself!
I command you by the allegiance you have sworn to
keep within proper bounds language against my crown
and dignity!” A general clamour rose against
the prelate, and the chancellor, louder than the rest,
talked of the bishop’s oath of fealty to the
king, and warned him to take heed to himself.
Hilary, seeing himself thus beset, obsequiously declared
that he had no wish to take aught from the kingly
honour and dignity, which he had always bent every
effort to magnify and increase; but Henry bluntly
retorted that it was plain to all that his honour
and dignity would be speedily removed far from him
by the fair and deceitful talk of those who would
annul his just prerogatives. The bishop could
not find a single friend. Chancellor and justiciar
and constable rivalled one another in taunts and sharp
phrases. When he went on to urge the revision
of the Conqueror’s charter to Battle by the
archbishop, and to appeal to ecclesiastical custom,
Henry’s wrath rose again. “A wonderful
and marvellous thing truly is this we hear, that the
charters, forsooth, of my kingly predecessors, confirmed
by the prerogative of the Crown of England, and witnessed
by the magnates, should be deemed beyond our powers
by you, my lord bishop. God forbid, God forbid,
that in my kingdom what is decreed by me at the instance
of reason, and with the advice of my archbishops,
bishops, and barons, should be liable to the censure
of you and such as you!” He broke short discussion