That any obligations should overpower their attention to profit, we have known them long enough not to expect.  It is not to be expected from a more liberal people.  With what kindness they repay benefits, they are now showing us, who, as soon as we have delivered them from France, are defying and proscribing us.

But if we will permit them to tax themselves, they will give us more than we require.  If we proclaim them independent, they will, during pleasure, pay us a subsidy.  The contest is not now for money, but for power.  The question is not, how much we shall collect, but, by what authority the collection shall be made.

Those who find that the Americans cannot be shown, in any form, that may raise love or pity, dress them in habiliments of terrour, and try to make us think them formidable.  The Bostonians can call into the field ninety thousand men.  While we conquer all before us, new enemies will rise up behind, and our work will be always to begin.  If we take possession of the towns, the colonists will retire into the inland regions, and the gain of victory will be only empty houses, and a wide extent of waste and desolation.  If we subdue them for the present, they will universally revolt in the next war, and resign us, without pity, to subjection and destruction.

To all this it may be answered, that between losing America, and resigning it, there is no great difference; that it is not very reasonable to jump into the sea, because the ship is leaky.  All those evils may befall us, but we need not hasten them.

The dean of Gloucester has proposed, and seems to propose it seriously, that we should, at once, release our claims, declare them masters of themselves, and whistle them down the wind.  His opinion is, that our gain from them will be the same, and our expense less.  What they can have most cheaply from Britain, they will still buy; what they can sell to us at the highest price, they will still sell.

It is, however, a little hard, that, having so lately fought and conquered for their safety, we should govern them no longer.  By letting them loose before the war, how many millions might have been saved.  One wild proposal is best answered by another.  Let us restore to the French what we have taken from them.  We shall see our colonists at our feet, when they have an enemy so near them.  Let us give the Indians arms, and teach them discipline, and encourage them, now and then, to plunder a plantation.  Security and leisure are the parents of sedition.

While these different opinions are agitated, it seems to be determined, by the legislature, that force shall be tried.  Men of the pen have seldom any great skill in conquering kingdoms, but they have strong inclination to give advice.  I cannot forbear to wish, that this commotion may end without bloodshed, and that the rebels may be subdued by terrour rather than by violence; and, therefore, recommend such a force as may take away, not only the power, but the hope of resistance, and, by conquering without a battle, save many from the sword.