Marianne listened, still smiling, but with tears standing in her eyes.  A feeling of gentle sadness was penetrating her; her heart-wound had reopened even amid all her joy at seeing her children assembled around her.  “Yes,” said she in a trembling voice, “there have been twelve, but I have only ten left.  Two are already sleeping yonder, waiting for us underground.”

There was no sign of dread, however, in that evocation of the peaceful little cemetery of Janville and the family grave in which all the children hoped some day to be laid, one after the other, side by side.  Rather did that evocation, coming amid that gay wedding assembly, seem like a promise of future blessed peace.  The memory of the dear departed ones remained alive, and lent to one and all a kind of loving gravity even amid their mirth.  Was it not impossible to accept life without accepting death.  Each came here to perform his task, and then, his work ended, went to join his elders in that slumber of eternity where the great fraternity of humankind was fulfilled.

But in presence of those jesters, Beauchene and Seguin, quite a flood of words rose to Mathieu’s lips.  He would have liked to answer them; he would have liked to triumph over the mendacious theories which they still dared to assert even in their hour of defeat.  To fear that the earth might become over-populated, that excess of life might produce famine, was this not idiotic?  Others only had to do as he had done:  create the necessary subsistence each time that a child was born to them.  And he would have pointed to Chantebled, his work, and to all the corn growing up under the sun, even as his children grew.  They could not be charged with having come to consume the share of others, since each was born with his bread before him.  And millions of new beings might follow, for the earth was vast:  more than two-thirds of it still remained to be placed under cultivation, and therein lay endless fertility for unlimited humanity.  Besides, had not every civilization, every progress, been due to the impulse of numbers?  The improvidence of the poor had alone urged revolutionary multitudes to the conquest of truth, justice, and happiness.  And with each succeeding day the human torrent would require more kindliness, more equity, the logical division of wealth by just laws regulating universal labor.  If it were true, too, that civilization was a check to excessive natality, this phenomenon itself might make one hope in final equilibrium in the far-off ages, when the earth should be entirely populated and wise enough to live in a sort of divine immobility.  But all this was pure speculation beside the needs of the hour, the nations which must be built up afresh and incessantly enlarged, pending the eventual definitive federation of mankind.  And it was really an example, a brave and a necessary one, that Marianne and he were giving, in order that manners and customs, and the idea of morality and the idea of beauty might be changed.