[-11-] “That this is so I will show you clearly, Conscript Fathers, by going over each point in detail.  Antony did say some words during his tribuneship in Caesar’s behalf:  Cicero and some others spoke in behalf of Pompey.  Why now does he accuse him of preferring one man’s friendship, but acquit himself and the rest who warmly embraced the opposite cause?  Antony, to be sure, hindered at that time some measures adverse to Caesar from being passed:  and Cicero hindered practically everything that was known to be favorable to Caesar.  ‘But Antony obstructed,’ he replies, ’the public judgment of the senate.’  Well, now, in the first place, how could one man have had so much power?  Second, if he had been condemned for this, as is said, how could he have escaped punishment?  ’Oh, he fled, he fled to Caesar and got out of the way.’  Of course you, Cicero, did not ‘leave town’ just now, but you fled, as in your former exile.[16] Don’t be so ready to apply your own shame to all of us.  To flee is what you did, in fear of the court, and pronouncing condemnation on yourself beforehand.  Yes, to be sure, an ordinance was passed for your recall; how and for what reasons I do not say, but at any rate it was passed, and you did not set foot in Italy before the recall was granted.  But Antony both went away to Caesar to inform him what had been done and returned, without asking for any decree, and finally effected peace and friendship with him for all those that were found in Italy.  And the rest, too, would have had a share in it, if they had not taken your advice and fled. [-12-] Now in view of those circumstances do you dare to say he led Caesar against his country and stirred up the civil war and became more than any one else responsible for the subsequent evils that befell us?  Not so, but you, who gave Pompey legions that belonged to others and the command, and undertook to deprive Caesar even of those that had been given him:  it was you, who agreed with Pompey and the consuls not to accept the offers made by Caesar, but to abandon the city and the whole of Italy:  you, who did not see Caesar even when he entered Rome, but had run off to Pompey and into Macedonia.  Not even to him, however, did you prove of any assistance, but you neglected what was going on, and then, when he met with misfortune, you abandoned him.  Therefore you did not aid him at the outset on the ground that he had the juster cause, but after setting in motion the dispute and embroiling affairs you lay in wait at a safe distance for a favorable turn; you at once deserted the man who failed, as if that somehow proved him guilty, and went over to the victor, as if you deemed him more just.  And in addition to your other defects you are so ungrateful that not only are you not satisfied to have been preserved by him, but you are actually displeased that you were not made master of the horse.