[Martin Mull] is a songwriter of almost depressingly facile wit and also the purveyor of one of the funniest club acts in the history of Western civilization. Unfortunately, his studio albums are disappointing, lacking both audience feedback and the visual antics of Mull himself.

[I'm Everyone I've Ever Loved] is no exception. Despite some marvelous material (the title tune, a disco parody to end all disco parodies, the thoroughly scandalous Humming Song) and valiant support by an all-star cast …, it is only fitfully amusing, which is not what I want from a man who in performance has reduced me to rolling uncontrollably in some very crowded aisles.

Steve Simels, "Popular Discs and Tapes: 'I'm Everyone I've Ever Loved'," in Stereo Review (copyright © 1977 by Ziff-Davis Publishing Company), Vol. 38, No. 5, May, 1977, p. 90.