One of the handsomest, most perfectly conceived and executed albums I've heard in recent months is Did She Mention My Name?… Lightfoot is a romantic, to be sure, but he is a clear-eyed realist at the same time; the combination results in songs that are lyrical, full of tenderness and compassion, but above all real, honest, and totally without artifice. The whole album is a gas, but especially memorable are the lovely Pussywillows, Cat-tails; The Last Time I Saw Her; The Mountain and Maryann, and the title song, Did She Mention My Name? Unqualifiedly recommended. This is in every respect an essential set.

Pete Welding, in his review of "Did She Mention My Name?" in down beat (copyright 1969; reprinted with permission of down beat), Vol. 36, No. 5, March 6, 1969, p. 29.